diff --git a/src/views/pay/app/ChannelModal.vue b/src/views/pay/app/ChannelModal.vue
index f4db72d..fdde5d4 100644
--- a/src/views/pay/app/ChannelModal.vue
+++ b/src/views/pay/app/ChannelModal.vue
@@ -14,12 +14,12 @@ const emit = defineEmits(['success', 'register'])
 const { t } = useI18n()
 const { createMessage } = useMessage()
 const isUpdate = ref(true)
-const type = ref(PayType.ALIPAY)
+const appType = ref(PayType.ALIPAY)
 
 const [registerForm, { setFieldsValue, resetFields, validate }] = useForm({
   labelWidth: 120,
   baseColProps: { span: 24 },
-  schemas: type.value === PayType.ALIPAY ? aliPayFormSchema : (type.value === PayType.WECHAT ? weChatFormSchema : mockFormSchema),
+  schemas: appType.value === PayType.ALIPAY ? aliPayFormSchema : (appType.value === PayType.WECHAT ? weChatFormSchema : mockFormSchema),
   showActionButtonGroup: false,
   actionColOptions: { span: 23 },
 })
@@ -28,12 +28,12 @@ const [registerModal, { setModalProps, closeModal }] = useModalInner(async (data
   resetFields()
   setModalProps({ confirmLoading: false })
   isUpdate.value = !!data?.isUpdate
-  type.value = data.type
+  appType.value = data.type
   if (unref(isUpdate)) {
     const res = await getChannel(data.record.id, data.payCode)
     const config = JSON.parse(res.config)
     const payConfig: any = {}
-    if (type.value === PayType.ALIPAY) {
+    if (appType.value === PayType.ALIPAY) {
       payConfig.appId = config.appId
       payConfig.serverUrl = config.serverUrl
       payConfig.signType = config.signType
@@ -44,7 +44,7 @@ const [registerModal, { setModalProps, closeModal }] = useModalInner(async (data
       payConfig.alipayPublicCertContent = config.alipayPublicCertContent
       payConfig.rootCertContent = config.rootCertContent
     }
-    else if (type.value === PayType.WECHAT) {
+    else if (appType.value === PayType.WECHAT) {
       payConfig.appId = config.appId
       payConfig.apiVersion = config.apiVersion
       payConfig.mchId = config.mchId
diff --git a/src/views/pay/app/index.vue b/src/views/pay/app/index.vue
index fa5f5e5..a94cc5b 100644
--- a/src/views/pay/app/index.vue
+++ b/src/views/pay/app/index.vue
@@ -63,6 +63,19 @@ async function handleDelete(record: Recordable) {
 function openChannel(record: Recordable, payCode: string, type: string, isUpdate: boolean) {
   openChannelModal(true, { record, payCode, type, isUpdate })
 }
+
+/**
+ * 根据渠道编码判断渠道列表中是否存在
+ *
+ * @param channels 渠道列表
+ * @param channelCode 渠道编码
+ */
+function isChannelExists(channels, channelCode) {
+  if (!channels)
+    return false
+
+  return channels.includes(channelCode)
+}
 </script>
 
 <template>
@@ -79,7 +92,7 @@ function openChannel(record: Recordable, payCode: string, type: string, isUpdate
       <template #bodyCell="{ column, record }">
         <template v-if="column.key === PayChannelEnum.ALIPAY_APP.code">
           <a-button
-            v-if="record.channelCodes.indexOf(PayChannelEnum.ALIPAY_APP.code) !== -1"
+            v-if="isChannelExists(record.channelCodes, PayChannelEnum.ALIPAY_APP.code)"
             type="primary"
             shape="circle"
             @click="openChannel(record, PayChannelEnum.ALIPAY_APP.code, PayType.ALIPAY, true)"
@@ -98,7 +111,7 @@ function openChannel(record: Recordable, payCode: string, type: string, isUpdate
         </template>
         <template v-if="column.key === PayChannelEnum.ALIPAY_PC.code">
           <a-button
-            v-if="record.channelCodes.indexOf(PayChannelEnum.ALIPAY_PC.code) !== -1"
+            v-if="isChannelExists(record.channelCodes, PayChannelEnum.ALIPAY_PC.code)"
             type="primary"
             shape="circle"
             @click="openChannel(record, PayChannelEnum.ALIPAY_PC.code, PayType.ALIPAY, true)"
@@ -117,7 +130,7 @@ function openChannel(record: Recordable, payCode: string, type: string, isUpdate
         </template>
         <template v-if="column.key === PayChannelEnum.ALIPAY_WAP.code">
           <a-button
-            v-if="record.channelCodes.indexOf(PayChannelEnum.ALIPAY_WAP.code) !== -1"
+            v-if="isChannelExists(record.channelCodes, PayChannelEnum.ALIPAY_WAP.code)"
             type="primary"
             shape="circle"
             @click="openChannel(record, PayChannelEnum.ALIPAY_WAP.code, PayType.ALIPAY, true)"
@@ -136,7 +149,7 @@ function openChannel(record: Recordable, payCode: string, type: string, isUpdate
         </template>
         <template v-if="column.key === PayChannelEnum.ALIPAY_QR.code">
           <a-button
-            v-if="record.channelCodes.indexOf(PayChannelEnum.ALIPAY_QR.code) !== -1"
+            v-if="isChannelExists(record.channelCodes, PayChannelEnum.ALIPAY_QR.code)"
             type="primary"
             shape="circle"
             @click="openChannel(record, PayChannelEnum.ALIPAY_QR.code, PayType.ALIPAY, true)"
@@ -155,7 +168,7 @@ function openChannel(record: Recordable, payCode: string, type: string, isUpdate
         </template>
         <template v-if="column.key === PayChannelEnum.ALIPAY_BAR.code">
           <a-button
-            v-if="record.channelCodes.indexOf(PayChannelEnum.ALIPAY_BAR.code) !== -1"
+            v-if="isChannelExists(record.channelCodes, PayChannelEnum.ALIPAY_BAR.code)"
             type="primary"
             shape="circle"
             @click="openChannel(record, PayChannelEnum.ALIPAY_BAR.code, PayType.ALIPAY, true)"
@@ -174,7 +187,7 @@ function openChannel(record: Recordable, payCode: string, type: string, isUpdate
         </template>
         <template v-if="column.key === PayChannelEnum.WX_LITE.code">
           <a-button
-            v-if="record.channelCodes.indexOf(PayChannelEnum.WX_LITE.code) !== -1"
+            v-if="isChannelExists(record.channelCodes, PayChannelEnum.WX_LITE.code)"
             type="primary"
             shape="circle"
             @click="openChannel(record, PayChannelEnum.WX_LITE.code, PayType.WECHAT, true)"
@@ -193,7 +206,7 @@ function openChannel(record: Recordable, payCode: string, type: string, isUpdate
         </template>
         <template v-if="column.key === PayChannelEnum.WX_PUB.code">
           <a-button
-            v-if="record.channelCodes.indexOf(PayChannelEnum.WX_PUB.code) !== -1"
+            v-if="isChannelExists(record.channelCodes, PayChannelEnum.WX_PUB.code)"
             type="primary"
             shape="circle"
             @click="openChannel(record, PayChannelEnum.WX_PUB.code, PayType.WECHAT, true)"
@@ -212,7 +225,7 @@ function openChannel(record: Recordable, payCode: string, type: string, isUpdate
         </template>
         <template v-if="column.key === PayChannelEnum.WX_APP.code">
           <a-button
-            v-if="record.channelCodes.indexOf(PayChannelEnum.WX_APP.code) !== -1"
+            v-if="isChannelExists(record.channelCodes, PayChannelEnum.WX_APP.code)"
             type="primary"
             shape="circle"
             @click="openChannel(record, PayChannelEnum.WX_APP.code, PayType.WECHAT, true)"
@@ -231,7 +244,7 @@ function openChannel(record: Recordable, payCode: string, type: string, isUpdate
         </template>
         <template v-if="column.key === PayChannelEnum.MOCK.code">
           <a-button
-            v-if="record.channelCodes.indexOf(PayChannelEnum.MOCK.code) !== -1"
+            v-if="isChannelExists(record.channelCodes, PayChannelEnum.MOCK.code)"
             type="primary"
             shape="circle"
             @click="openChannel(record, PayChannelEnum.MOCK.code, PayType.MOCK, true)"